Schleich Horse Club Starter Set vs Individual Horses: Which to Buy?
By GASCHer's Spielwarenshop | Published: 2026-10-26
Category: Comparisons
Deciding between the Schleich Horse Club Starter Set and buying individual horses? We compare the value, variety, and flexibility of each option to help you choose.
Quick Answer
For a ready-to-play herd, the Schleich Horse Club Starter Set offers better value per figure and instant variety. For a focused collection or specific breeds, buying individual horses like the Schleich Pinto Stute gives you more control.
Value vs. Specificity
The main trade-off is between getting more for your money and getting exactly what you want. The Starter Set includes five figures at a lower per-figure cost compared to buying them individually. However, you don't get to choose which horses are in the box. If you have your heart set on a particular breed or color, like the Pinto Stute with its unique spotted coat, buying it alone is the only way to guarantee you get it.
Trade-offs at a Glance
- Value per Figure: The Starter Set gives you five figures for around $30.80, compared to a single figure like the Pinto Stute at $13.46. You save money per horse.
- Variety vs. Choice: The set offers a pre-selected variety of breeds and ages. Buying individually lets you pick each horse's breed, color, and pose.
- Collection Completeness: The set is a perfect foundation for a new Horse Club collection. Individual horses are better for filling gaps or finding rare or special-painted models. Consider if you want a broad start or a specific addition.
Product Facts
- Schleich Horse Club Starter-Set: This set contains five beautifully designed horse figures, including a Paint Horse foal, an Appaloosa mare, a Quarter Horse foal, and an Arabian mare. You get a diverse small herd in one purchase, which is ideal for immediate imaginative play or starting a collection.
Schleich Horse Club Starter-Set - Schleich 72138 Pinto Stute Sonderbemalung: This Pinto mare has a brown coat, dark mane and tail, and beautiful white spots. Her coat pattern will be passed on to her foal. If you are looking for a specific coat pattern or want to breed realistic foals in your play, this figure offers that specific feature.
Schleich 72138 Pinto Stute Sonderbemalung
Which Option Fits You?
Best for
- New collectors or kids wanting an instant play set
- Gift-givers who want a substantial present without guessing preferences
Not ideal for
- Collectors seeking a specific breed or rare paint job
- Budget-focused buyers who only need one horse
